Why Poor Places Are More Diverse

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the intriguing relationship between biodiversity and nutrient-poor soils, highlighting that areas with limited resources, such as tropical rainforests and shrublands, often support a greater variety of species compared to regions with nutrient-rich soils. This pattern is mirrored in human societies, where poorer regions tend to have more small businesses and greater cultural diversity. Ultimately, the lesson emphasizes that some of the poorest environments can be the richest in terms of ecological and cultural diversity, shaped by factors like time and stability.

Why Poor Places Are More Diverse

Imagine a soccer-field-sized area of forest in chilly Alaska. It has around 40 different plant species. Now, compare that to about 70 species in the milder climate of England and a whopping 300 in the lush Amazon rainforest. This pattern of biodiversity isn’t just limited to small patches of land; it extends to entire countries. For instance, England boasts 1,500 plant species, while tropical Guyana has even more. The incredible diversity found in tropical rainforests is rivaled by another unique ecosystem: the scrubby, fire-prone shrublands of western Australia and southern Africa. Although these shrublands might not seem as grand as rainforests, they are home to an equally impressive variety of species.

The Role of Nutrient-Poor Soils

Both tropical rainforests and shrublands owe their rich biodiversity partly to their nutrient-poor soils, which are low in essential nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus. These nutrients are crucial for plant growth. Interestingly, the world’s top biodiversity hotspots are found in areas with nutrient-poor soils. It might seem logical to assume that richer soils would support more species, but in nature, as in human society, having abundant resources doesn’t always mean everyone benefits equally.

In ecosystems like meadows, forests, and wetlands, we often see larger plants but fewer species where soil nutrients are abundant. Fast-growing species quickly absorb most of the extra nutrients, allowing them to grow rapidly. This growth advantage helps them access more water and sunlight, leaving slower-growing species with fewer resources, which may lead to their decline. On the other hand, poor soils don’t provide enough nutrients for fast-growing plants to dominate, allowing a wider variety of species to coexist.

Parallels in Human Society

This pattern is also evident in human societies. In poorer countries, there tends to be a greater number of small businesses, while wealthier nations often have fewer but larger companies. However, poor soil isn’t the only factor contributing to high diversity. Environments frequently affected by harsh weather or catastrophic events often have poor soils and fewer plant species.

The Importance of Time

Time is another crucial factor for high diversity. Glaciers regularly reshape ecosystems and create new soil, but our high-diversity rainforests and shrublands have remained undisturbed for millions of years. This stability has allowed their inhabitants to evolve a wide range of strategies for surviving in nutrient-poor conditions. As a result, we see tall, diverse rainforests thriving in wet, nutrient-poor soils and scrubby, diverse shrublands flourishing in dry, nutrient-poor soils.

Human Cultural and Linguistic Diversity

The human landscape follows a similar pattern. The highest cultural and linguistic diversity, along with the greatest number of businesses, is found in regions with stable climates where humans have lived the longest and where economic resources are limited. In this sense, some of the poorest places on Earth can also be considered the richest in terms of diversity.

Supporting Biodiversity Conservation

This exploration of biodiversity is supported by the Kwongan Foundation at the University of Western Australia, which is dedicated to conserving Australia’s remarkable biodiversity. To learn more about the ecology of the hyper-diverse Kwongan ecosystem, you can explore “Plant Life on the Sandplains in Southwest Australia” or visit the Kwongan Foundation online. A special thanks to the Kwongan Foundation for making this educational content possible.

  1. How does the concept of nutrient-poor soils contributing to biodiversity challenge your previous understanding of ecosystems?
  2. Can you draw any parallels between the biodiversity in nutrient-poor environments and diversity in human societies?
  3. What insights did you gain about the relationship between environmental stability over time and biodiversity?
  4. How might the information about biodiversity in poor soils influence conservation efforts in your local area?
  5. Reflect on the idea that some of the poorest places on Earth can be the richest in terms of diversity. How does this perspective shift your view on poverty and wealth?
  6. What role do you think human cultural and linguistic diversity plays in the overall diversity of a region?
  7. How can the lessons learned from natural ecosystems be applied to fostering diversity in human communities?
  8. What actions can individuals or communities take to support biodiversity conservation, inspired by the article’s discussion?
  1. Interactive Map Analysis

    Explore an interactive map that highlights global biodiversity hotspots. Analyze the correlation between soil nutrient levels and species diversity in different regions. Discuss your findings with peers and consider how these patterns relate to the concepts discussed in the article.

  2. Case Study Presentation

    Research a specific ecosystem, such as the Amazon rainforest or the shrublands of western Australia. Prepare a presentation that explains how nutrient-poor soils contribute to biodiversity in your chosen ecosystem. Highlight any unique species and their adaptations to the environment.

  3. Debate on Resource Distribution

    Participate in a debate about the impact of resource distribution on biodiversity. Argue whether nutrient-rich or nutrient-poor environments are more beneficial for sustaining diverse ecosystems. Use examples from the article to support your position.

  4. Field Experiment Design

    Design a hypothetical field experiment to test the effects of soil nutrient levels on plant diversity. Outline your methodology, including how you would measure biodiversity and control variables. Share your experimental design with classmates for feedback.

  5. Cultural Diversity Comparison

    Investigate a region with high cultural and linguistic diversity. Compare its environmental and economic conditions to those described in the article. Write a short essay discussing the parallels between ecological and human diversity in this context.

A soccer-field-sized patch of forest in frigid Alaska has about 40 different species of plants, compared with about 70 in temperate England and 300 in the Amazon rainforest. These biodiversity differences hold true for entire countries as well: England has 1,500 plant species, while tropical Guyana has even more. The super-diversity of tropical rainforests is only matched by another type of ecosystem on Earth: scrubby, fire-prone shrublands found in western Australia and southern Africa. While these shrublands may not appear as majestic as tropical rainforests, they host similarly impressive numbers of species.

However, both ecosystems owe their enormous diversity, in part, to their soils, which have critically low supplies of nitrogen and especially phosphorus—nutrients essential for plant growth. The leading biodiversity hotspots in the plant world are, quite literally, nutrient-poor. Logically, it seems that richer soils should support more species, but in nature, as in human society, having plenty of resources doesn’t necessarily mean that everyone benefits equally.

In meadows, forests, and wetlands around the world, we often find larger plants but fewer species where soil nutrients are highest. Fast-spreading species absorb most of the extra nutrients, allowing them to grow rapidly, which in turn enables their roots to access more water and their leaves to capture more sunlight. As a result, slower species receive less of these resources and may die out. Conversely, poor soils do not provide enough nutrients for fast-growing plants to thrive, allowing a greater variety of species to coexist.

This pattern can also be observed in human society, where there tends to be a greater number of small businesses in poorer countries, while fewer larger companies dominate in wealthier nations. However, poor soil isn’t the only factor contributing to high diversity; environments frequently affected by harsh weather or catastrophic events often have poor soils and fewer plant species.

Another major factor for high diversity is time. Glaciers regularly reshape ecosystems and create new soil, but our high-diversity rainforests and shrublands have remained undisturbed for millions of years, allowing their inhabitants to evolve a wide variety of strategies for surviving in nutrient-poor conditions. This has led to the development of tall, diverse rainforests in wet, nutrient-poor soils and scrubby, diverse shrublands in dry, nutrient-poor soils.

The human landscape appears to follow a similar pattern, with the highest cultural and linguistic diversity, as well as the greatest number of businesses, found in climatically stable regions where humans have lived the longest and where economic resources are limited. Thus, in some ways, the poorest places on Earth can also be considered the richest.

This episode of MinuteEarth is supported by the Kwongan Foundation at the University of Western Australia, which promotes the conservation of Australia’s remarkable biodiversity. To learn more about the ecology of the hyper-diverse Kwongan ecosystem, check out “Plant Life on the Sandplains in Southwest Australia” or visit the Kwongan Foundation online. Thank you to the Kwongan Foundation for making this MinuteEarth video possible.

BiodiversityThe variety and variability of life forms within a given ecosystem, biome, or the entire Earth, often used as a measure of the health of biological systems. – The Amazon rainforest is renowned for its high biodiversity, hosting millions of different species of plants and animals.

EcosystemsCommunities of living organisms in conjunction with the nonliving components of their environment, interacting as a system. – Coral reefs are complex ecosystems that support a wide range of marine life.

NutrientsSubstances that provide nourishment essential for the growth and maintenance of life. – Nutrients from decomposed organic matter enrich the soil, promoting plant growth in forest ecosystems.

SpeciesA group of living organisms consisting of similar individuals capable of exchanging genes or interbreeding. – The introduction of invasive species can disrupt local ecosystems and threaten native biodiversity.

SoilsThe upper layer of earth in which plants grow, a black or dark brown material typically consisting of a mixture of organic remains, clay, and rock particles. – Healthy soils are crucial for sustainable agriculture and maintaining ecosystem services.

ConservationThe protection, preservation, management, or restoration of natural environments and the ecological communities that inhabit them. – Conservation efforts are essential to protect endangered species and their habitats from further decline.

RainforestsDense forests rich in biodiversity, found typically in tropical areas with consistently heavy rainfall. – Rainforests play a critical role in regulating the Earth’s climate and are home to a vast array of species.

ShrublandsVegetation dominated by shrubs, often found in regions with a Mediterranean climate. – Shrublands provide important habitats for wildlife and are adapted to withstand periodic fires.

EvolutionThe process by which different kinds of living organisms are thought to have developed and diversified from earlier forms during the history of the earth. – The theory of evolution explains the adaptation of species to their environments over time.

DiversityThe state of being diverse; variety, especially in the context of biological systems where it refers to the range of different species and genetic variability within a population. – Genetic diversity within a species is crucial for its ability to adapt to changing environmental conditions.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?