It’s a question that has puzzled people from ancient Greek times to the 21st century, and we’re still curious: What came first, the chicken or the egg?
If we take the question literally, it’s quite simple. Animals that lay eggs existed long before chickens did, so technically, the egg came first. But if we ask: which came first, the chicken or the chicken egg? This question dives into a cycle of cause and effect. If a chicken hatches from an egg, where did the egg come from? Presumably, another chicken, which also must have come from an egg.
Some people argue in favor of the chicken. Research suggests that a crucial protein for forming chicken eggs, called OV-17, is only found in chicken ovaries. Without it, a chicken egg’s shell couldn’t form. So, without a chicken, you can’t get a chicken egg. But this all depends on how we define a chicken egg. Is it an egg laid by a chicken, or simply one that contains a chicken? If an elephant laid an egg that hatched a lion, would it be an elephant egg or a lion egg?
On the other hand, there’s the egg argument. During reproduction, two organisms pass on their genetic information as DNA, but this DNA replication is never 100% accurate, often resulting in small changes in the new organism. These tiny DNA mutations over thousands of generations create new species. These genetic mutations occur in the zygote or initial cell, so a creature very similar to a chicken (let’s call it a proto-chicken) would have mated with another proto-chicken and, due to a small genetic mutation, created the first chicken, which grew inside an egg.
So, was the egg first? Chicken supporters might argue it was a chicken growing in a proto-chicken egg. However, no single mutation can truly define a new species. While humans like to classify creatures into different groups and names, this is based on how things are now, not how they were millions of years ago. Evolution is so gradual that the transition from proto-chicken to chicken wouldn’t have been considered a new species at the time.
Take dogs, for example, which come from wolves. Since humans began interacting with and domesticating wolves, there’s no exact point where a wolf gave birth to a dog. Instead, certain traits emerged due to selective pressures, like choosing wolves that weren’t afraid of humans or were less aggressive. Over many generations, we’ve seen significant differences in behavior and genetic traits.
So, where does this leave us? We have two scenarios: some ancient egg-laying species gradually led to the creation of a proto-chicken, which laid proto-chicken eggs. In one of these eggs, a mutation caused a slight change, a selective advantage that led to the first chicken, which started laying chicken eggs. In this case, technically, the chicken came first. Or, we have a proto-chicken that gave birth to a chicken inside what we might classify as a chicken egg, and in that case, the egg was first.
This brings us back to the question: what is a chicken egg? It’s a question without a clear answer because, in the end, what we can all agree on is that regardless of whether it was a chicken egg or a proto-chicken egg, the first chicken came from an egg. The egg was first.
Do you have an interesting question you’d like answered? Ask in the comments, or on Facebook and Twitter. Subscribe to see more science videos every week.
Form two groups and hold a debate on whether the chicken or the egg came first. Use the information from the article to support your arguments. Consider the role of proteins like OV-17 and genetic mutations in your discussion. This will help you understand different perspectives and the complexity of the topic.
Choose an animal and research its evolutionary history. Create a timeline that shows how small genetic mutations over generations led to the species we know today. Present your findings to the class to illustrate the gradual process of evolution.
Write a short story from the perspective of a proto-chicken. Describe its environment, interactions, and how it might have contributed to the evolution of the modern chicken. This activity will help you think creatively about evolutionary concepts.
Conduct a simple experiment to understand DNA mutations. Use colored beads to represent DNA sequences and simulate mutations by changing bead colors. Discuss how these changes can lead to new traits over generations. This hands-on activity will help you grasp the concept of genetic variation.
Participate in a class discussion about what defines a species. Consider the gradual changes in evolution and how humans classify animals. Reflect on the example of dogs and wolves from the article. This will encourage critical thinking about biological classification.
Aquí tienes el texto del transcript sanitizado:
—
Es una pregunta que ha tenido perpleja a la humanidad desde los antiguos griegos hasta el siglo XXI, y todavía estamos ansiosos por saber: ¿Qué fue primero, la gallina o el huevo?
La pregunta sería sencilla si la tomamos literalmente. Animales que ponen huevos existieron mucho antes de que lo hicieran las gallinas, por lo que técnicamente el huevo fue antes que la gallina. Pero si la pregunta fuera: ¿fue primero la gallina o el huevo de gallina? Esta pregunta se referiría a la causa y consecuencia cíclica. Es decir, si una gallina nace de un huevo, ¿de dónde vino el huevo? De otra gallina, presumiblemente, que también debe haber venido de un huevo.
Entonces, ¿cuál fue primero? Por un lado, tenemos a los partidarios de la gallina. Investigaciones sugieren que la proteína esencial para la formación de los huevos de gallina, llamada OV-17, solo se encuentra en los ovarios de la gallina. Sin ella, la cáscara del huevo de gallina no podría formarse. Así que, sin una gallina, no se podría obtener un huevo de gallina. Pero todo esto depende de la naturaleza y la definición de un huevo de gallina. Después de todo, ¿es un huevo de gallina un huevo puesto por una gallina o simplemente uno que contiene una gallina? Obviamente, la gallina portadora de OV-17 tuvo que venir de alguna parte. Pero si un elefante pone un huevo del que nace un león, ¿sería un huevo de elefante o un huevo de león?
Esto lleva a la otra cara de la historia, la de los partidarios del huevo. Durante la reproducción, dos organismos transmiten su información genética en forma de ADN, pero la réplica de este ADN nunca es 100% precisa y con frecuencia se producen pequeños cambios en el nuevo organismo. Estas pequeñas mutaciones en el ADN durante miles de generaciones crean nuevas especies. Estas mutaciones genéticas se producen en el cigoto o célula inicial, de modo que una criatura muy similar a una gallina (que podríamos llamar proto-gallina) se habría apareado con otra proto-gallina y, debido a una pequeña mutación genética, habrían creado a la primera gallina, la cual creció en un huevo.
Entonces, ¿fue primero el huevo? Los partidarios de la gallina podrían argumentar que se trataba de una gallina creciendo en un huevo de proto-gallina. Sin embargo, ninguna mutación puede realmente constituir una nueva especie. Si bien a los humanos nos gusta clasificar a todas las criaturas en diferentes grupos y nombres, esto se basa en cómo son las cosas actualmente y no en cómo eran millones de años atrás. El proceso de evolución es tan gradual que el paso de una proto-gallina a una gallina no se habría considerado una nueva especie en aquel momento.
Miremos el caso de los perros, los cuales provienen de los lobos. Desde el momento en que el hombre empezó a interactuar y a domesticar a estos últimos, no existe un punto exacto en el que un lobo dio a luz a un perro. En cambio, ciertos rasgos particulares surgieron debido a presiones selectivas, como la elección de lobos que no temieran a los humanos o los que eran menos agresivos. Así, durante varias generaciones hemos concebido grandes diferencias en comportamiento y rasgos genéticos.
Entonces, ¿en dónde nos deja esto? Tenemos dos escenarios: alguna especie ovípara antigua llevó gradualmente a la creación de una proto-gallina, la cual puso huevos de proto-gallina. En uno de estos huevos hubo una mutación que causó un cambio leve, una ventaja selectiva que llevó a la primera gallina, la que empezó a poner huevos de gallina. En este caso, técnicamente la gallina llegó primero, o tenemos una proto-gallina que dio a luz a una gallina dentro de lo que podríamos clasificar como un huevo de gallina, y en ese caso, el huevo fue primero.
Lo cual nos lleva de nuevo a la nomenclatura y a la pregunta: ¿qué es un huevo de gallina? La cual es una pregunta sin sentido, porque al fin y al cabo, en lo que todos podemos estar de acuerdo es que, independientemente de si se trataba de un huevo de gallina o un huevo de proto-gallina, la primera gallina vino de un huevo. El huevo fue primero.
¿Tienes una pregunta interesante que quieres que sea resuelta? Pregunta en los comentarios, o en Facebook y Twitter. Suscríbete para ver más vídeos de ciencia cada semana.
—
He eliminado algunas repeticiones y he ajustado el texto para que fluya mejor, manteniendo el contenido original.
Chicken – A domesticated bird that is often raised for its eggs and meat. – In biology class, we learned how the chicken is an example of a species that has been selectively bred for certain traits.
Egg – A reproductive cell produced by female animals, including birds, reptiles, and some mammals, which can develop into a new organism. – The teacher explained that the egg of a chicken contains all the nutrients needed for the embryo to develop.
DNA – The molecule that carries the genetic instructions used in the growth, development, functioning, and reproduction of all known living organisms. – Scientists study DNA to understand how traits are passed from parents to offspring.
Mutation – A change in the DNA sequence that can lead to variations in traits and sometimes result in new characteristics in organisms. – The mutation in the butterfly’s DNA caused it to have a unique wing pattern.
Species – A group of similar organisms capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring. – The Galápagos Islands are home to many unique species that have evolved in isolation.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms over generations. – Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution explains how species adapt to their environments over time.
Organism – An individual living entity that can react to stimuli, reproduce, grow, and maintain homeostasis. – Every organism, from the smallest bacterium to the largest whale, plays a role in its ecosystem.
Reproduction – The biological process by which new individual organisms are produced from their parents. – Reproduction is essential for the survival of a species, allowing it to pass on its genetic material to the next generation.
Protein – A molecule composed of amino acids that performs a variety of functions in the body, including building tissues and acting as enzymes. – Proteins are crucial for the structure and function of all living cells and viruses.
Zygote – The cell formed by the fusion of two gametes, marking the beginning of a new organism’s development. – After fertilization, the zygote undergoes multiple divisions to eventually form a complete organism.
