In the mid-19th century, Ireland faced a catastrophic event known as the Irish Famine. Imagine living in a time when one in six people around you succumbed to starvation or disease. This tragedy led to the death of 1 million people and forced another 1.5 million to leave the country, permanently altering Ireland’s demographic landscape. The culprit behind this devastation was a fungus called Phytophthora infestans, or late blight, which attacked the potato crops that the Irish population heavily depended on for sustenance.
Late blight remains a significant threat to potato and tomato growers worldwide, costing the global potato industry around five billion dollars annually. Although some potatoes have been bred to resist this fungus, the process is lengthy and often requires farmers to use fungicides regularly. However, in 2015, scientists developed a genetically modified (GM) potato, known as the Innate Potato, which is resistant to late blight. By incorporating blight-resistant genes from wild potato plants, this innovation has the potential to save farmers time and money while significantly reducing pesticide use.
The debate surrounding GMOs is often polarized, with some viewing them as harmful and others as a solution to global challenges like hunger and climate change. To navigate this complex issue, it’s essential to understand what GMOs are. Genetically modified organisms are those whose genetic material has been altered using genetic engineering techniques. This involves identifying a trait of interest, isolating it, inserting it into the desired organism, and then propagating that organism.
Many GMOs today are engineered to enhance quality, tolerate drought, or resist pests. For instance, BT maize is a type of insect-resistant corn that produces proteins toxic to pests like the European corn borer, significantly reducing the need for insecticides.
GMOs offer several advantages, including combating malnutrition. Vitamin A deficiency is a major public health issue, especially in regions where rice is a staple food. Scientists have developed Golden Rice, a GM rice variety that produces beta-carotene, a precursor to vitamin A, which can prevent deficiency-related blindness in children.
Extensive research, including over 500 scientific studies, has not found conclusive risks to human health from GM crops. For example, BT toxins require specific conditions to be harmful, which humans do not possess. Despite this, opposition to GMOs persists, often fueled by misinformation and unscientific claims.
While GMOs have potential benefits, they are not without challenges. One issue is the use of herbicide-resistant crops, such as those tolerant to glyphosate. This has led to increased herbicide use, raising environmental and health concerns. Glyphosate has been declared “probably carcinogenic” by the World Health Organization, and its long-term effects are still debated.
The public perception of GMOs often diverges from scientific consensus, with many people believing GM foods are harmful. This gap is sometimes exploited by entities spreading anti-GMO sentiments to undermine trust in science.
Despite the controversies, GMOs hold promise for addressing global challenges like climate change and food security. Gene-edited crops can potentially reduce agricultural emissions and minimize harmful chemical use if properly regulated. However, outright opposition to GMOs can hinder progress and deny access to beneficial technologies, especially for the world’s poorest populations.
As we consider the future of food, it’s crucial to engage in informed discussions about the role of genetic engineering. By understanding the complexities of GMOs, we can make better decisions for a sustainable future.
For more insights into food and farming solutions, you can explore the documentary “The Future of Food” on CuriosityStream. This platform offers a wide range of documentaries and nonfiction titles, along with access to Nebula, a streaming site featuring educational content from YouTube creators. By subscribing to CuriosityStream, you support educational content creators and gain access to exclusive videos.
Engage in a structured debate with your classmates on the pros and cons of GMOs. Divide into two groups, with one supporting GMOs as a solution to global challenges and the other opposing them due to potential risks. Use evidence from scientific studies and the article to support your arguments. This will help you understand different perspectives and develop critical thinking skills.
Conduct research on a specific GMO crop, such as Golden Rice or BT maize. Prepare a presentation that covers its development, benefits, challenges, and public perception. Present your findings to the class to enhance your understanding of the complexities involved in GMO technology and its impact on society.
Analyze a case study on the use of GMOs in agriculture, such as the Innate Potato. Discuss the scientific, economic, and ethical aspects of the case in small groups. This activity will help you apply theoretical knowledge to real-world scenarios and understand the multifaceted nature of GMO applications.
Watch the documentary “The Future of Food” on CuriosityStream. After viewing, participate in a class discussion about the insights gained from the documentary. Reflect on how the information presented aligns or contrasts with the article’s content. This will broaden your understanding of food and farming solutions.
Attend an interactive workshop or lab session where you can learn about genetic engineering techniques used to create GMOs. Participate in hands-on activities, such as DNA extraction or gene editing simulations, to gain practical experience. This will deepen your comprehension of the scientific processes behind GMOs.
This episode of Real Science is brought to you by CuriosityStream. Watch thousands of documentaries for free for 31 days at curiositystream.com/realscience.
The 1840s were a challenging time in Irish history. Imagine one in every six people you know slowly and painfully dying of starvation or disease. In the following years, many people left the country and never returned. Over the next few decades, the population of your town could be half of what it used to be. During the Irish Famine, 1 million people, or about 15% of the population, died. Another 1.5 million people fled the country in its immediate aftermath, leading to a permanent decline in the Irish population. Ireland and the world were changed forever due to one persistent and devastating fungus.
Late blight, or Phytophthora infestans, is a fungus that attacks the potato plant, rendering the potatoes inedible. The fungus spores spread easily in the wind and quickly infect neighboring plants. This was particularly disastrous for Ireland, where the rural poor heavily relied on potatoes for food. By the 1850s, the widespread blight eventually ran its course, but it did not disappear entirely. To this day, blight remains a significant problem for potato and tomato growers that must be battled year after year.
160 years after the famine, late blight is still a five billion dollar problem for the global potato industry. Some potatoes can be bred to have some resistance to the fungus, but this can take decades. Therefore, farmers often need to spray their crops with fungicides every week indefinitely. However, in 2015, a breakthrough occurred: a new variety of GMO potato was developed that can resist the very blight that caused so much devastation. Using blight-resistant genes from wild potato plants, scientists precisely adapted a version of the common potato to withstand the fungal disease. This GM potato, called the Innate Potato, can save farmers significant amounts of time and money and can reduce the amount of environmentally damaging pesticide sprayed on the fields by up to eighty or ninety percent.
Naturally, Ireland, with its history of massive crop failure and commitment to green agriculture, has decided to ban it and even attempt to ban all GMOs. So what is going on? We’ve all probably seen debates like this. Some argue that GMOs are harmful, while others claim they will end world hunger and stop climate change. The amount of unresearched and unscientific claims out there is overwhelming. There is an ever-present sense of hysteria when discussing anything related to GMOs, and this public sentiment informs government decisions, often for the worse.
However, the issue of GMOs is not as black and white as many would lead you to believe. GMOs are not the solution to all problems, nor are they the cause of all harm. Before we delve into whether GMOs are good or bad, let’s first understand what they are. Genetically modified organisms are organisms that have been altered using genetic engineering methods. The key steps involved in genetic engineering include identifying a trait of interest, isolating that trait, inserting it into a desired organism, and then propagating or breeding that organism.
Most GMOs on the market today have been given genetic traits to improve their quality, provide tolerance to drought, or protect against pests, like the GM potato mentioned earlier. Another significant example in the world of GM foods is insect resistance. BT maize, for example, is a strain of insect-resistant corn. Corn farmers face numerous pests, but the most damaging are caterpillars and beetle grubs. The European corn borer, for instance, has been nicknamed the “billion-dollar bug” because it costs growers over a billion dollars annually in insecticides and lost crop yields.
In 1996, farmers were introduced to genetically engineered corn with resistance to the European corn borer. These genetically modified plants produce proteins derived from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis, hence the name BT maize. The proteins produced by the bacteria are toxic to caterpillars like the corn borer and are introduced into the corn through a process called transgenesis.
The first step in this process is identifying an organism with the desired trait—something toxic to caterpillars. Scientists discovered that a naturally occurring soil bacterium was responsible for the deaths of silkworms, and it was found to be toxic to the European corn borer as well. The next step is to extract the desired DNA from the bacteria, which involves separating the DNA from other parts of the cell and isolating the gene of interest.
The transgene is then inserted into the corn using various techniques, such as a gene gun or electroporation. The goal is to deliver the transgene into the nucleus of a cell without killing it. The cells can then be treated with plant hormones, allowing them to grow into an entire plant. The result is corn crops that contain their own insect resistance. This has two major benefits: the corn crops are less likely to be destroyed by caterpillars, and less insecticide is needed to combat them. Studies have shown a significant decrease in insecticide use when BT or similar crops are planted.
GMO crops can also help combat malnutrition in many parts of the world. Vitamin A deficiency has been recognized as a significant public health problem for over 30 years, particularly in populations where rice is the staple food. White rice contains no micronutrients, and vitamin A deficiency is the leading cause of preventable blindness in children. To address this, scientists engineered what is called Golden Rice, which produces beta-carotene, the precursor of vitamin A. Just one cup of golden rice per day can prevent vitamin A deficiency and has the potential to save thousands of lives.
While it is impossible to prove that a food is completely safe, over 500 scientific studies have failed to find conclusive risks to human health from GM crops. For example, many studies have confirmed that BT toxins require specific conditions to be toxic, which humans do not possess. Other methods scientists use to test GM foods include simulating the behavior of GM proteins in the human gut and testing GM crops on animal models.
Despite many studies failing to find harmful effects, there is still significant opposition to GMOs. In 2013, anti-GMO activists destroyed a field trial for Golden Rice in the Philippines, delaying the study and jeopardizing the technology’s implementation. Ireland is also attempting to impose blanket restrictions on GMOs, citing the need to maintain its international reputation as a green, sustainable food producer.
This raises the question: why are people so opposed to something that seems beneficial? While misinformation and bogus claims abound, it is important to recognize that the rise of GMOs has not been without its issues. One common type of GMO crop is resistant to herbicides, specifically glyphosate. Roundup Ready is a trademark for genetically modified crop seeds that are resistant to glyphosate-based herbicides. This means farmers can use more herbicide on their crops. Studies show that adopters of glyphosate-tolerant soybeans use significantly more herbicide than non-adopters, and global glyphosate use has risen dramatically since these crops were introduced.
Glyphosate can leak into soil and water, affecting wild plants and animals, and the World Health Organization has declared it probably carcinogenic. There are ongoing concerns about its long-term effects, especially for those who use it regularly. Monsanto is currently facing lawsuits from individuals alleging that Roundup caused their cancer, with significant jury awards in some cases.
This is a nuanced conversation, and any doubts about this complex subject can be easily exploited. Surveys show that a significant percentage of the public believes GM foods are worse for health, and there is a notable gap between public opinion and expert consensus on the issue. Additionally, evidence has emerged that foreign entities have been spreading anti-GMO sentiments to undermine public trust in science.
While it is essential to criticize corporations like Monsanto for their practices, it is also crucial to rigorously study the role of GMOs in our world. To oppose GMOs outright is overly simplistic. Ireland’s push to prohibit genetically modified crops contradicts its climate action ambitions, and it is misleading to equate GMO-free status with sustainability. Gene-edited crops have the potential to reduce climate emissions in agriculture and minimize harmful chemicals in the environment if regulated properly.
A recent report highlighted that Ireland ranks poorly in tackling climate change and is unlikely to meet its EU commitments. Yet, the push to ban GMOs continues, ignoring a valuable tool in addressing these challenges. Politicians should consider the parallels between their own country’s history and the struggles faced by those suffering from malnutrition and crop failures elsewhere.
As plant geneticist Pamela Ronald has noted, the loud arguments and misinformation about plant genetics may deny the poorest people access to technology that could benefit them. The future of our society is linked to the future of food, and genetic engineering is one of many ways to sustain the growing population.
You can learn more about different food and farming solutions in the documentary titled “The Future of Food” on CuriosityStream. CuriosityStream offers thousands of documentaries and nonfiction titles from some of the world’s best filmmakers. An annual subscription also includes access to Nebula, a streaming site created by educational YouTube content creators.
The next Real Science video is already available on Nebula, along with other exclusive content. To access all of this, sign up at curiositystream.com/realscience, and you’ll receive an email with a link for your free Nebula subscription. By signing up for CuriosityStream, you’ll be supporting educational content creators as we work together to create exciting new original videos.
GM – Genetically Modified – The term “GM” refers to organisms whose genetic material has been altered using genetic engineering techniques. Example sentence: The development of GM crops has significantly increased agricultural productivity by enhancing resistance to pests and diseases.
GMO – Genetically Modified Organism – A GMO is an organism whose genome has been engineered in the laboratory in order to favor the expression of desired physiological traits or the generation of desired biological products. Example sentence: The use of GMOs in agriculture has sparked a global debate about food safety and environmental impact.
Agriculture – The science, art, and practice of cultivating the soil, growing crops, and raising livestock – Agriculture plays a crucial role in sustaining human populations by providing food, fiber, and other essential resources. Example sentence: Advances in sustainable agriculture are essential to meet the food demands of a growing global population while minimizing environmental impact.
Environment – The complex of physical, chemical, and biotic factors that act upon an organism or an ecological community – The environment is a critical factor in determining the health and survival of species and ecosystems. Example sentence: Human activities have significantly altered the environment, leading to climate change and biodiversity loss.
Sustainability – The ability to maintain ecological and resource balance over the long term – Sustainability in environmental studies focuses on meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Example sentence: Implementing sustainable practices in agriculture can help preserve natural resources and reduce environmental degradation.
Biotechnology – The use of living systems and organisms to develop or make useful products – Biotechnology has revolutionized the field of medicine and agriculture by enabling the development of new treatments and genetically modified crops. Example sentence: The application of biotechnology in agriculture has led to the creation of crops that are more resistant to drought and pests.
Crops – Plants cultivated for food, fiber, or other resources – Crops are essential for human survival, providing the majority of the world’s food supply. Example sentence: The introduction of high-yielding crop varieties has helped to increase food production in many parts of the world.
Pests – Organisms that damage crops, livestock, or forestry – Pests can cause significant economic losses in agriculture by reducing crop yields and quality. Example sentence: Integrated pest management strategies aim to control pest populations while minimizing harm to the environment.
Health – The state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being – Health is influenced by a variety of factors, including genetics, environment, and lifestyle choices. Example sentence: Environmental health studies examine how environmental factors impact human health and well-being.
Food – Any nutritious substance that people or animals eat or drink to maintain life and growth – Food security is a major concern in environmental studies, as it relates to the availability and access to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food. Example sentence: The global food system faces challenges such as climate change, population growth, and resource scarcity.
