One of the most intriguing mysteries in biology revolves around some of its tiniest inhabitants: single-celled plankton that live in the ocean. The big question is, why are there so many different species of plankton?
In most natural settings, when similar species share the same habitat and compete for the same resources, usually only one species thrives. The others either go extinct or adapt to different roles. For instance, in California, two similar plants, tarweeds and rosinweeds, often grow on the same rocky hillsides. Over time, rosinweeds tend to dominate, causing tarweeds to decline. Similarly, in the northeastern United States, different bird species that once competed for resources in spruce trees have adapted to different parts of the tree. The Cape May warbler now occupies the top, while other warblers have moved lower down.
Even a slight advantage, like the rosinweeds’ ability to grow faster in shallow soil, can lead to one species becoming dominant. Mathematical models that simulate these interactions often predict that one species will eventually outcompete the others.
Plankton, however, seem to break this rule. Despite competing for the same resources in the same thin layer of ocean water, thousands of similar plankton species coexist. So, what’s going on here?
One idea is that the models we use might not accurately represent the real conditions plankton experience. The constant mixing of water by wind and waves might prevent any single plankton species from gaining a lasting advantage. Each disturbance could reset the competition, much like how tarweeds and rosinweeds start growing together again after a disruption.
Another possibility is that while the models are correct, they might be applied incorrectly. When scientists collect plankton using nets, they might be sampling from different micro-environments, each with its own mix of resources. This could make it seem like the species are peacefully coexisting, when in fact, each species might dominate its own specific micro-environment.
Recently, many researchers have considered a third explanation: the models are accurate but can lead to unexpected outcomes. When modeling five or more species competing for three or more resources, the system can become chaotic, preventing any clear winner from emerging. This chaos might explain why so many plankton species can coexist.
Even with all our knowledge about the world, there is still much to learn about its inhabitants, including the seemingly simple single-celled plankton. Their ability to coexist in such large numbers continues to challenge our understanding of nature.
Research the concept of the “Plankton Paradox” and prepare a short presentation. Focus on explaining why this paradox challenges traditional ecological models. Use visuals and examples from the article to support your points. Present your findings to the class.
Using a computer simulation tool, model the competition between different plankton species. Experiment with variables such as resource availability and environmental disturbances. Observe how these changes affect species dominance and coexistence. Share your observations in a group discussion.
Participate in a class debate on the possible explanations for the plankton paradox. Divide into groups, with each group defending one of the explanations mentioned in the article. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your argument.
Write a short story from the perspective of a plankton species living in the ocean. Describe the challenges and interactions with other plankton species. Use the concepts from the article to illustrate the complexity of plankton coexistence.
Design a field study to investigate the coexistence of plankton species in a local water body. Outline the methods you would use to collect and analyze data, considering the potential micro-environments and resource distribution. Present your proposal to the class for feedback.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
One of the biggest mysteries in biology centers around one of its smallest organisms: single-celled ocean-dwelling plankton. Specifically, why are there so many different species?
In most instances, when similar species live in the same place and compete for the same resources, only one species succeeds, while the others either go extinct or adapt. For example, in California, when nearly identical plants known as tarweeds and rosinweeds grow on the same rocky hillside, the rosinweeds tend to take over, leading to the decline of the tarweeds. Similarly, in the American northeast, different bird species that once competed for the same resources in spruce trees have shifted their roles; the Cape May warbler now dominates the top of the tree, while other warbler species have adapted to live lower down.
In these situations, even a small difference, like the rosinweeds’ slightly faster growth in shallow soil, can provide a consistent advantage, resulting in one species emerging as the dominant one. These outcomes are supported by mathematical models that simulate how interactions between similar species will unfold, consistently predicting that one species will prevail.
Plankton, however, seem to defy this winner-take-all rule. Despite competing for the same resources in the same thin layer of the ocean, thousands of similar plankton species coexist. What could explain this?
One possibility is that the models may not accurately reflect the conditions in which plankton live. Wind and waves could be mixing the water enough that no single plankton species has the opportunity to fully exploit any small advantage and outcompete others. Each disturbance might reset the competition, similar to how tarweeds and rosinweeds start growing together.
Another possibility is that while the models are correct, they may be misapplied. When scientists collect plankton from the ocean using a plankton net, they might be sampling various micro-environments, each with a different combination of resources. This could create the illusion of peaceful coexistence among species, when in reality, each species might dominate its own unique micro-environment.
Recently, many researchers have leaned toward a third explanation: the models are accurate but can sometimes produce unexpected results. When modeling five or more species competing for three or more resources, the system can become chaotic, preventing any clear winner from emerging. This phenomenon may also explain the coexistence of numerous plankton species.
Ultimately, as much as we know about the world, there is still much to learn about its inhabitants, even those as seemingly simple as single-celled sea-dwellers.
—
Let me know if you need any further modifications!
Plankton – Small and microscopic organisms drifting or floating in the sea or freshwater, consisting chiefly of diatoms, protozoans, small crustaceans, and the eggs and larval stages of larger animals. – Plankton form the base of the aquatic food web, providing an essential source of nutrition for larger marine animals.
Species – A group of living organisms consisting of similar individuals capable of exchanging genes or interbreeding. – The discovery of a new species of frog in the Amazon rainforest has excited biologists around the world.
Resources – Natural substances or materials that organisms need to survive, grow, and reproduce. – The availability of resources such as sunlight and water can significantly affect the distribution of plant species in an ecosystem.
Competition – The interaction between organisms or species that vie for the same resources in an ecosystem, such as food, space, or light. – In the dense forest, competition for sunlight is fierce among the tall trees.
Coexist – To live in the same habitat or environment without competing destructively. – Different species of birds can coexist in the same tree by occupying different niches and feeding at different times.
Models – Representations or simulations used to understand and predict biological processes or phenomena. – Scientists use climate models to predict how global warming might affect biodiversity in the coming decades.
Environments – The surroundings or conditions in which an organism lives, including all living and non-living factors. – Organisms must adapt to their environments to survive, which can lead to evolutionary changes over time.
Chaos – A state of unpredictability and apparent randomness in complex systems, often observed in ecological or biological contexts. – The introduction of an invasive species can cause chaos in an ecosystem, disrupting the balance and leading to unforeseen consequences.
Biology – The scientific study of life and living organisms, including their structure, function, growth, evolution, and distribution. – Advances in molecular biology have revolutionized our understanding of genetic diseases.
Ocean – A vast body of saltwater that covers almost three-quarters of the Earth’s surface and is home to diverse marine life. – The ocean plays a crucial role in regulating the Earth’s climate by absorbing carbon dioxide and heat.
