Once upon a time, most mushrooms in the forest were busy breaking down dead leaves and wood on the forest floor. These mushrooms were known as “decomposers.” But over millions of years, some mushrooms have come up with a new way to survive, leading to an interesting battle: decomposers versus symbiotic mushrooms.
Hi, I’m David, and welcome to MinuteEarth. Instead of just feeding on dead stuff, symbiotic mushrooms have teamed up with trees. They grow long, thin strands that connect to a tree’s roots, helping the tree soak up more nutrients and water. In return, the mushrooms get some of the tree’s sugary sap, which is why we call them symbiotic mushrooms.
If you love mushrooms, you might know these types because their sweet diet makes them tasty. But before they end up on our plates, they face off against decomposers. Even though their strategies are different, they both need one thing: nitrogen, which is found in decomposing material.
All mushrooms need nitrogen to build proteins and other important stuff. So, symbiotic mushrooms have to find nitrogen in the soil, which leads to competition. Decomposers, not being tied to trees, can spread out and find nitrogen first. They use special enzymes to break it down and store it before symbiotic mushrooms can get to it.
If symbiotic mushrooms can’t get enough nitrogen, they might die, and decomposers can feast on their remains. But symbiotic mushrooms have tricks up their sleeves. They can stretch out straw-like strands to suck nitrogen away from decomposers. Some, like black truffles, even produce chemicals to harm nearby mushrooms.
These clever tactics have helped symbiotic mushrooms take over more than two-thirds of the world’s forests. This is great for forests because symbiotic mushrooms help trees grow better and survive droughts. It’s good for us too; forests with these mushrooms are 20% better at removing carbon from the air than those with decomposers.
However, human activities might be giving decomposers a boost. The nitrogen used in farming can leak into forests, helping decomposers thrive. Plus, air pollution can damage the trees that symbiotic mushrooms rely on, slowing their growth. So, while symbiotic mushrooms are currently in the lead, decomposers are catching up.
In the end, it’s still unclear which group will win this ongoing ecological battle.
This video was made possible by the University of Minnesota and a grant from the National Science Foundation. Peter Kennedy’s lab at the university’s College of Biological Sciences studies how plants and microbes interact, focusing on ectomycorrhizal fungi, which are the symbiotic mushrooms. Professor Kennedy and his team are researching how these fungi help forests absorb carbon. They want to understand how these effects vary based on factors like tree species and soil depth. To learn more about their research, check out Professor Kennedy’s website in the description. Thank you!
Using materials like clay, paper, and string, build a 3D model of a forest floor ecosystem. Include both decomposer and symbiotic mushrooms, and demonstrate how they interact with trees and the soil. Explain your model to the class, highlighting the roles of each type of mushroom in the ecosystem.
Participate in a role-playing game where you take on the role of either a decomposer or a symbiotic mushroom. Develop strategies to gather nitrogen and support your survival. Discuss with your classmates how your strategies affect the forest ecosystem and the balance between decomposers and symbiotic mushrooms.
Research a specific type of symbiotic mushroom, such as black truffles, and create a presentation about its unique adaptations and role in the forest ecosystem. Present your findings to the class, focusing on how these mushrooms compete with decomposers for resources.
Engage in a class debate where you argue for the importance of either symbiotic or decomposer mushrooms in forest ecosystems. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your position. Discuss the potential impacts of human activities on each type of mushroom.
Take a field trip to a local forest or park to observe mushrooms in their natural habitat. Identify examples of decomposer and symbiotic mushrooms, and note their interactions with the environment. Back in class, share your observations and discuss how these mushrooms contribute to the forest ecosystem.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
A long time ago, most forest mushrooms primarily fed on decomposing material on the forest floor. You could say they were “decomposers.” However, over the past few million years, various species from the mushroom kingdom have evolved a new strategy, leading to a fascinating dynamic: it’s the decomposers versus the symbiotic mushrooms.
Hi, I’m David, and this is MinuteEarth. Instead of relying solely on dead material for sustenance, the symbiotic mushrooms have formed an alliance with trees. These mushrooms develop long, thin tendrils that intertwine and connect to a tree’s roots, enhancing the tree’s ability to absorb nutrients and water. In return, the mushrooms gain access to the tree’s sugary sap, which is why they are referred to as symbiotic mushrooms.
If you’re a mushroom enthusiast, you might already be familiar with these mushrooms, as their sugary diet makes them quite appealing for consumption. However, before they reach our plates, they are in competition with the decomposers. The two groups have such different strategies that they might seem to have little reason to compete. Yet, there is one essential resource that symbiotic mushrooms lack from their partnership with trees: nitrogen, which is abundant in decomposing material.
All mushrooms require nitrogen to form proteins and other vital compounds. Therefore, symbiotic mushrooms must seek nitrogen in the surrounding soil, leading to competition. Since decomposers are not tied to trees and can spread their reach widely, they often discover nitrogen first. They utilize specialized enzymes to break it down quickly and store it before the symbiotic mushrooms can access it.
Symbiotic mushrooms that cannot obtain enough nitrogen may perish, and the decomposers can take advantage of this by consuming the remains. However, the symbiotic mushrooms have developed strategies to counteract this. They can extend straw-like tendrils to siphon nitrogen away from the decomposers. Additionally, some symbiotic mushrooms have evolved chemical defenses; for instance, black truffles can produce toxins that harm nearby mushrooms.
These strategies have allowed symbiotic mushrooms to outmaneuver the decomposers, leading them to dominate more than two-thirds of forests worldwide. This shift has been beneficial for the forests, as symbiotic mushrooms enhance trees’ growth and resilience to drought. This is advantageous for humans as well; forests dominated by symbiotic mushrooms are 20% more effective at removing carbon from the atmosphere compared to those dominated by decomposers.
However, human activities may inadvertently support the decomposers. The large amounts of nitrogen used in agriculture can seep into nearby forests, allowing decomposers to thrive. Additionally, air pollution can harm the trees that symbiotic mushrooms depend on, hindering their growth. Thus, while the symbiotic mushrooms are currently prevailing, the decomposers have gained some momentum.
In summary, it remains uncertain which group will ultimately prevail in this ongoing ecological competition.
This video was made possible by the University of Minnesota and a grant from the National Science Foundation. Peter Kennedy’s lab in the university’s College of Biological Sciences studies the interactions between plants and microbes, focusing on ectomycorrhizal fungi, which are the symbiotic mushrooms. Professor Kennedy, along with his colleagues, is researching how these fungi enhance forests’ capacity to absorb carbon. They aim to understand the geographical extent of these effects and how they vary based on ecological factors such as tree species and soil depth. To learn more about their research, check out Professor Kennedy’s website in the description. Thank you!
—
This version removes any potentially sensitive or inappropriate language while maintaining the original meaning and context.
Mushrooms – A type of fungi that grows above ground and is often seen as a cap on a stalk. – Mushrooms play an important role in ecosystems by breaking down organic matter.
Decomposers – Organisms that break down dead or decaying organisms, recycling nutrients back into the ecosystem. – Decomposers like bacteria and fungi are essential for nutrient cycling in forests.
Symbiotic – A relationship between two different organisms where both benefit from the association. – Lichens are an example of a symbiotic relationship between fungi and algae.
Nitrogen – A chemical element that is essential for the growth of plants and is a major component of the atmosphere. – Nitrogen is crucial for plant growth as it is a key component of chlorophyll.
Trees – Large perennial plants with a trunk, branches, and leaves, playing a crucial role in ecosystems. – Trees provide oxygen and habitat for many species in the forest.
Nutrients – Substances that provide nourishment essential for growth and the maintenance of life. – Plants absorb nutrients from the soil to grow and produce food.
Competition – The struggle between organisms to survive in a habitat with limited resources. – In a dense forest, there is competition among trees for sunlight and water.
Carbon – A chemical element that is a fundamental building block of life and is found in all living organisms. – Carbon is cycled through the environment in processes like photosynthesis and respiration.
Fungi – A group of organisms that includes yeasts, molds, and mushrooms, which decompose organic material. – Fungi are important decomposers in ecosystems, breaking down dead plants and animals.
Forests – Large areas covered chiefly with trees and undergrowth, providing habitat for diverse species. – Forests are vital for maintaining biodiversity and regulating the Earth’s climate.
