Today, we know that water is made up of hydrogen and oxygen, but a couple of hundred years ago, people thought differently. Back then, water was considered an element, meaning it was seen as a basic building block of the universe that couldn’t be broken down into anything simpler.
In the early 1780s, chemists noticed something interesting: when they burned a certain gas, a lot of water was produced. This made them wonder if the water was being created during the burning process or if it was just coming from moisture in the air. To figure this out, they set up an experiment using a sealed container that didn’t let any air in or out. They put the gas inside and found that it wouldn’t burn by itself. It needed another gas to ignite. When they combined both gases and set them on fire inside the container, only water was produced.
This experiment showed that water could be made from simpler substances, proving it wasn’t an element. Chemists also found ways to break water down into its parts, with electrolysis being the easiest method. Electrolysis uses electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen gases.
By 1808, a chemist named John Dalton tried to show what a water molecule looked like. He thought it was made of one hydrogen atom and one oxygen atom, or HO. Although this was incorrect, it was the best guess at the time. Experiments had shown that water was made of two parts hydrogen for every one part oxygen, but they didn’t yet know how many atoms were in each part.
An Italian chemist made a big discovery by proving that equal volumes of different gases have the same number of molecules. He found out that both hydrogen and oxygen are diatomic, meaning each molecule is made of two atoms. This helped chemists understand that two molecules of hydrogen combine with one molecule of oxygen to form two molecules of water. So, the correct formula for water is H2O, meaning two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Even though we now know water is H2O, it took a lot of research and teamwork among chemists to figure this out. The symbols for hydrogen and oxygen that we use today come from Dalton’s early work in chemistry. While we have more accurate symbols and models now, learning about these developments can be fascinating.
If you’re interested in exploring more about chemistry and other subjects, you might want to check out Brilliant, an interactive learning platform for math, science, and computer science. They offer courses that make learning fun and engaging. Visit brilliant.org/MinuteEarth to learn more, and the first 200 people to sign up will get a 20% discount on Brilliant’s annual premium subscription. Happy learning!
Try to recreate a simple version of the experiment that led to the discovery that water is not an element. Use safe materials like baking soda and vinegar to produce gas, and observe the reaction. Discuss what happens and why it is significant in understanding water’s composition.
Conduct a demonstration of electrolysis using a small battery, water, and salt. Watch as the water splits into hydrogen and oxygen gases. Discuss how this process helped chemists understand that water is made of simpler substances.
Use molecular model kits to build water molecules. Start with Dalton’s incorrect HO model and then build the correct H2O model. Discuss the importance of accurate models in scientific understanding.
Explore the concept of diatomic molecules by measuring the volume of different gases. Use balloons to capture gas from reactions and compare their volumes. Discuss how this relates to the discovery of water’s composition.
Create a timeline of key discoveries in the understanding of water’s composition. Include important figures like John Dalton and the Italian chemist who discovered diatomic molecules. Discuss how each discovery contributed to our current knowledge.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Today, the composition of the water molecule is widely understood, but two centuries ago, it was perceived quite differently. In ancient times, people believed water was an element, a fundamental building block of the universe. They thought that because water was an element, it could not be broken down further or created from simpler substances.
However, in the early 1780s, chemists began to observe that burning a particular gas produced a significant amount of water. This raised the question: was the water being created through combustion, or was it simply coming from moisture in the air? To investigate, chemists constructed an airtight vessel, isolated from the atmosphere, and introduced the gas. They found that it did not ignite on its own, as another gas was necessary for combustion. Once both gases were combined in the vessel and ignited, the reaction produced only water.
This experiment demonstrated that water could be formed by combining simpler substances, indicating that water is not an element. Chemists also discovered methods to decompose water, with electrolysis being the simplest. Electrolysis employs an electric current to split water into its constituent gases—hydrogen and oxygen.
By 1808, John Dalton, a prominent chemist, created the first representation of the water molecule, depicting it as a combination of a hydrogen atom and an oxygen atom, or HO. While this was incorrect, Dalton was limited by the knowledge available at the time. Experiments had shown that water consisted of two volumes of hydrogen for every one volume of oxygen. However, this did not definitively prove that water is H2O, as they were working with gas volumes without knowing the number of atoms in each volume.
An Italian chemist made a significant advancement by establishing that equal volumes of different gases contain the same number of molecules. It turned out that both hydrogen and oxygen are diatomic molecules, meaning each consists of two atoms. This discovery confirmed that one volume of hydrogen has the same number of molecules as one volume of oxygen, leading to the conclusion that two molecules of hydrogen combine with one molecule of oxygen to form two molecules of water.
Thus, the water molecule is composed of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, or H2O. While this may seem like a straightforward fact today, uncovering the composition of water required extensive research and collaboration among leading chemists.
Additionally, the symbols for hydrogen and oxygen that we frequently use originate from Dalton’s “New System of Chemical Philosophy,” which included early representations of atoms and molecules. While we now utilize more precise symbols and models, you can learn about these advancements in a comprehensive course offered by Brilliant, the sponsor of this video. Brilliant provides interactive learning in math, science, and computer science. To explore this course and many others, visit brilliant.org/MinuteEarth. The first 200 individuals will receive a 20% discount on Brilliant’s annual premium subscription. Thank you, Brilliant!
—
This version maintains the essential information while removing any informal language and ensuring clarity.
Water – A transparent, tasteless, odorless, and nearly colorless chemical substance, which is the main constituent of Earth’s streams, lakes, and oceans, and the fluids of most living organisms. – Water is essential for life, and it is a compound made of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Hydrogen – A colorless, odorless, highly flammable gas, the chemical element with the symbol H and atomic number 1. – Hydrogen is the lightest element and is used in the process of electrolysis to produce oxygen and hydrogen gas from water.
Oxygen – A chemical element with the symbol O and atomic number 8, essential for respiration in most living organisms and a part of the water molecule. – Oxygen is necessary for combustion and is a key component of the air we breathe.
Molecule – The smallest particle in a chemical element or compound that has the chemical properties of that element or compound, made up of two or more atoms bonded together. – A water molecule consists of two hydrogen atoms bonded to one oxygen atom.
Chemistry – The branch of science that studies the properties, composition, and behavior of matter. – In chemistry class, we learned how different substances react with each other to form new compounds.
Experiment – A scientific procedure undertaken to make a discovery, test a hypothesis, or demonstrate a known fact. – Our chemistry experiment involved mixing different chemicals to observe the reaction and record the results.
Electrolysis – A chemical process that uses electricity to cause a chemical change, usually the decomposition of a compound into its elements. – During electrolysis of water, electricity is used to split water into hydrogen and oxygen gases.
Atoms – The basic units of matter and the defining structure of elements, consisting of a nucleus surrounded by electrons. – Atoms combine in various ways to form molecules, which make up the substances we see around us.
Gases – One of the states of matter, consisting of particles that have neither a defined volume nor shape, and are free to move past each other. – Many gases, like oxygen and nitrogen, are crucial components of the Earth’s atmosphere.
Discovery – The act of finding or learning something for the first time, often leading to new knowledge or understanding. – The discovery of the electron was a significant milestone in the field of chemistry and physics.
