Dinosaurs are fascinating creatures, and there are many things we still don’t know about them. We aren’t sure what they sounded like, why some had plates on their backs, or much about their mating habits. However, one thing we do have a good understanding of is their body temperatures.
It’s amazing that we can measure the body temperatures of dinosaurs, even though they have been extinct for millions of years. If they were alive today, it would be tricky to figure out where to place a thermometer on them! Despite this, scientists have found evidence that a giant dinosaur called a titanosaur had a body temperature of 38 degrees Celsius. Other dinosaurs had different temperatures; for example, an oviraptor was cooler at 32 degrees, while a duck-billed dinosaur called Maisauria was warmer at around 44 degrees. Most dinosaurs had body temperatures between 36 and 38 degrees, making them warmer than crocodiles but generally cooler than modern birds.
For a long time, scientists debated whether dinosaurs were warm-blooded, meaning they generated heat internally, or cold-blooded, meaning they absorbed heat from their surroundings. These terms are known as endothermy and ectothermy. Scientists have now figured out how to estimate dinosaur body temperatures, helping to resolve this debate.
The key to measuring dinosaur temperatures lies in a mineral called bioapatite, which is found in bones and teeth. Bioapatite is made up of carbon and oxygen, but not all atoms are the same. Some are heavier isotopes, like C-13 and O-18, which tend to bond with each other more than lighter isotopes. When temperatures rise, these heavy isotopes are less likely to bond. Therefore, bones formed at warmer temperatures have fewer bonds between heavy carbon and oxygen. By analyzing these bonds, scientists can estimate the temperature at which the bone formed.
Scientists use isotope ratios from modern animals like birds and crocodiles to calibrate their measurements. This allows them to determine specific dinosaur body temperatures. For example, they discovered that T. Rex had a body temperature of 38 degrees Celsius. The data suggests that most dinosaurs were warmer than their surroundings. T. Rex, for instance, likely maintained a body temperature about 15 degrees higher than the average air temperature of its time.
Some dinosaurs could adjust their body temperatures. The bird-like dinosaur Troodon had a high body temperature of 42 degrees but could lower it to as low as 29 degrees, possibly when food was scarce. Scientists learned about Troodon’s temperature changes by examining fossilized eggshells, which contain the same temperature-sensitive materials found in bones. It’s impressive that we can measure Troodon’s body temperature and detect fluctuations, given how little we know about this dinosaur.
Understanding how dinosaurs regulated their body temperatures helps us learn more about their lives and how they adapted to their environments. This knowledge also provides insight into the evolution of temperature regulation in modern animals.
Research the body temperatures of different dinosaurs mentioned in the article, such as the titanosaur, oviraptor, and Maisauria. Create a chart that compares their temperatures to modern animals like birds and crocodiles. Use this chart to discuss with your classmates how these temperatures might have influenced the dinosaurs’ lifestyles and habitats.
Conduct a simple experiment to understand isotope bonding. Use different colored beads to represent lighter and heavier isotopes of carbon and oxygen. Simulate how these isotopes bond at different temperatures by creating models with more or fewer bonds. Discuss how this relates to the bioapatite analysis used by scientists to determine dinosaur temperatures.
Participate in a class debate on whether dinosaurs were warm-blooded or cold-blooded. Use evidence from the article, such as the temperature data and the role of bioapatite, to support your arguments. Consider how these characteristics might have affected dinosaur behavior and survival.
Role-play as different dinosaurs with varying temperature adaptations, like Troodon. Discuss how you would adapt to changes in your environment, such as food scarcity or climate shifts. Share your strategies with the class and explore how these adaptations might have contributed to the dinosaurs’ evolutionary success.
Imagine you are a paleontologist analyzing fossilized eggshells to determine dinosaur temperatures. Create a mock lab report detailing your findings, including the temperature fluctuations of dinosaurs like Troodon. Present your report to the class, explaining how these findings help us understand dinosaur behavior and evolution.
Here’s a sanitized version of the YouTube transcript:
—
There are many things we don’t know about dinosaurs. For instance, we don’t know what they sounded like, why some had plates down their backs, or much about how they mated. However, there is one intriguing aspect we do understand with surprising confidence – their body temperatures.
[Arcadi:] Hi, I’m Arcadi. Cameron forgot to introduce himself, so I’m doing it for him. Let’s get started!
[Cameron:] It’s fascinating that we can measure the body temperatures of dinosaurs, considering they are all extinct. Even if they were alive, it would be challenging to determine where to place a thermometer. Nevertheless, we have good evidence that this giant titanosaur had a body temperature of 38 degrees Celsius. Other dinosaurs had varying temperatures; for example, this oviraptor had a cooler temperature of 32 degrees, while the duck-billed Maisauria had a warmer temperature around 44 degrees. Most dinosaurs we know of had body temperatures between 36 and 38 degrees, indicating they were warmer than crocodiles but generally cooler than modern birds.
For a long time, scientists debated whether dinosaurs maintained warm body temperatures by generating heat internally (endothermy) or by absorbing heat from their surroundings (ectothermy). These strategies are often referred to as warm-blooded or cold-blooded, although we have discussed the issues with those terms in a previous video. Regardless of the terminology, scientists have finally figured out how to infer dinosaur body temperatures to resolve this debate. Here’s how they do it.
Scientists can measure these temperatures thanks to a robust crystal-like mineral that accumulates in bones and teeth known as bioapatite. Bioapatite primarily consists of carbon and oxygen, but not all of those atoms are the same. Heavy isotopes, specifically C-13 and O-18, have a stronger attraction to each other than they do to the more common, lighter isotopes of carbon and oxygen. Therefore, when these atoms combine to form minerals, they don’t bond randomly. Instead, heavy isotopes are more likely to bond with each other than would occur by random chance. However, when temperatures rise, the heavy isotopes have a reduced likelihood of bonding with each other. Consequently, bones that form at warmer temperatures contain fewer bonds between heavy carbon and heavy oxygen than those formed at cooler temperatures. In essence, the ratio of bonded heavy isotopes in a bone sample can indicate the temperature at which the bone formed. While it’s not the same as taking a dinosaur’s temperature directly, it’s a close approximation.
By analyzing the isotope ratios of modern animals like birds and crocodiles, scientists can calibrate their measurements and determine specific dinosaur body temperatures from their isotope data. This is how we know that T. Rex had a body temperature of 38 degrees Celsius. The data collected suggests that most dinosaurs were likely warmer than their surrounding environments. For instance, T. Rex likely maintained a body temperature about 15 degrees higher than the average air temperature of its time. However, many dinosaurs likely employed a different strategy: they could maintain their body temperatures through a combination of internally generated heat and heat from their environment, and in some cases, they could even adjust their body temperatures.
Some dinosaurs appear to have taken this to an extreme. For example, the bird-like dinosaur Troodon had a notably high body temperature of 42 degrees but could lower its temperature to as low as 29 degrees, possibly when food was scarce. Scientists learned about Troodon’s fluctuating body temperature not by analyzing bones, as Troodon bones are incredibly rare, but by examining fossilized eggshells, which contain the same temperature-sensitive materials found in bone. It’s impressive that we can measure Troodon’s body temperature and detect fluctuations, given how little we know about this dinosaur.
If you’ve watched our videos before, you may have heard us mention Tab for a Cause, a simple browser extension that allows you to raise money for charity just by opening browser tabs. Currently, Tab for a Cause is collaborating with VoteAmerica to ensure every eligible American has their voice heard in our democracy. Simply download Tab for a Cause at the link in the description, and every tab you open will help promote voter participation in the upcoming election.
—
This version removes informal language and maintains a professional tone while preserving the essential information.
Dinosaurs – Dinosaurs are a group of reptiles that lived millions of years ago and are known for their large size and diverse species. – Scientists study dinosaur fossils to understand how these ancient creatures lived and evolved.
Temperature – Temperature is a measure of how hot or cold something is, often measured in degrees Celsius or Fahrenheit. – The temperature of a habitat can greatly affect the types of organisms that can live there.
Warm-blooded – Warm-blooded animals, or endotherms, can regulate their body temperature internally, keeping it constant regardless of the environment. – Birds and mammals are examples of warm-blooded animals that can survive in a variety of climates.
Cold-blooded – Cold-blooded animals, or ectotherms, rely on external sources to regulate their body temperature. – Reptiles, like lizards and snakes, are cold-blooded and often bask in the sun to warm up.
Bioapatite – Bioapatite is a mineral found in bones and teeth that can provide information about the diet and environment of ancient organisms. – By analyzing bioapatite in fossils, scientists can learn about the diets of prehistoric animals.
Isotopes – Isotopes are different forms of the same element that have the same number of protons but different numbers of neutrons. – The study of isotopes in rocks can help scientists determine the age of fossils.
Measurements – Measurements are the process of obtaining the size, length, or amount of something, typically using standard units. – Accurate measurements of fossil bones can help paleontologists estimate the size of extinct animals.
Evolution – Evolution is the process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms over time. – The theory of evolution explains how species adapt to their environments through natural selection.
Adaptations – Adaptations are traits that improve an organism’s ability to survive and reproduce in its environment. – The thick fur of polar bears is an adaptation that helps them survive in cold climates.
Fossils – Fossils are the preserved remains or traces of organisms that lived in the past, often found in sedimentary rock. – Fossils provide important evidence for understanding the history of life on Earth.
